Dietz Makes Herkimer Golf History with Second All-American Honor

Jaydon Dietz didn't just play four rounds at the NJCAA Division III Golf National Championship. He cemented his place in Herkimer College history.

Competing June 3-6 at Chautauqua Golf Club's demanding Lake Course, Dietz became the first two-time NJCAA All-American in Generals golf history. He joins an exclusive club that includes John Liemann (2004) and Evan Crouse (2023) as the only All-Americans the program has ever produced — but none have done it twice.

Dietz's four-day total of 306 (+18) came in a week that tested every part of his game. The sophomore from New York Mills, NY opened the championship with an up-and-down 81 in Round 1, fighting through early struggles on the front nine before steadying himself on the back. The next day, he fired back with a season-best 73 — a remarkable turnaround that featured birdies on holes 3 and 17 and only one score worse than bogey.

His third round saw a few hiccups, including a double bogey on the 11th hole, but he hung in for a 78. He capped off the tournament with a strong closing 74, marked by a two-under-par start through five holes and a steady finish.

That kind of resilience is nothing new for Dietz, who has been a cornerstone of Herkimer's lineup for two seasons. Known for his calm demeanor and consistent ball-striking, he's earned respect across Region III. 

Dietz entered nationals riding a standout season in Region III, where he finished second in the individual standings with a season scoring average of 77.00 — just behind SUNY Niagara's Eliel Rodriguez. His 2025 résumé included multiple rounds in the low 70s and top finishes across every major regional tournament, including a 78-81 at the Region III Championship.

The 72-hole national championship, hosted by Jamestown Community College, featured the top NJCAA Division III golfers from across the country. Chautauqua Golf Club, stretching more than 6,400 yards, played firm and fast throughout the week with tricky greens and demanding par threes.

While Dietz didn't walk away with a trophy, his performance left no doubt about his legacy at Herkimer. His final leaderboard position secured him All-American recognition for the second year in a row — a feat unmatched in the program's history.

With his Herkimer career now complete, Dietz closes out as one of the most accomplished golfers the Generals have ever seen. But more importantly, he's left a lasting impression on the program — one built on grit, growth, and quiet excellence.